Christmas in my family always meant cookies and candy.
This post contains affiliate links. As an Amazon Associate and Walmart Creator, I earn from qualifying purchases. I may also earn a commission through other affiliate programs at no extra cost to you. I only share products I genuinely find useful or interesting.
Whether it was Mimi’s Fantasy Fudge, my aunt’s peanut butter balls and lemon cookies, or Gram’s divinity, you could always count on something good whenever the family got together.
Mimi always made her fudge both with and without nuts because of my allergy. I still remember how much I looked forward to it. And Gram’s divinity? That was something special.
Nana made a chocolate pizza that she’d shape into a Christmas wreath or tree. There were wedding cookies, beautiful stained glass cookies with colorful candy windows, and all sorts of other homemade treats.
I loved making pecan pralines myself, but if you ask me to choose just one cookie, it’ll always be a simple, buttery shortbread.
Those are the Christmas sweets I remember most. Not necessarily the fanciest or most elaborate, but the ones that remind me of the people who made them.
So I’ve gathered 15 old-fashioned Christmas cookies and candy recipes inspired by those family gatherings, with a few more nostalgic favorites mixed in.
Christmas Cookie & Candy Making Essentials
Planning a little Christmas baking of your own? I’ve put together a collection of my favorite kitchen essentials for making old-fashioned cookies and homemade candy, from candy thermometers and cookie cutters to baking sheets and festive tins for sharing your treats.
Food allergy note. Several recipes contain peanuts or tree nuts. Check ingredient labels, use clean equipment to prevent cross-contact, and skip any treat if you’re unsure what’s in it or how it was prepared. Food allergy safety tips from FARE.
1. Fantasy Fudge
Mimi made Fantasy Fudge using the recipe from the marshmallow creme jar, or at least that’s how I remember it. She made it both with and without nuts, so there was always some I could enjoy.
This classic stovetop fudge is rich, chocolatey, and just the sort of candy that belongs on a Christmas sweets tray.
2. Old-Fashioned Peanut Butter Balls
My aunt’s peanut butter balls were another Christmas favorite. There’s something about the combination of creamy peanut butter and chocolate that makes these little candies so hard to resist.
This buckeye-style version is an easy no-bake addition to a holiday candy assortment.
3. Lemon Cookies
My aunt also made lemon cookies, and I always looked forward to those. Among all the rich chocolate and candy, a bright lemon cookie offers something a little different.
These lemon crinkle cookies have a soft center and a powdered sugar coating. They’re a recipe suggestion inspired by my aunt’s cookies, rather than a confirmed match for hers.
4. Old-Fashioned Divinity
Gram’s divinity was one of the Christmas treats I remember most vividly. She kept recipes collected from magazines and cookbooks, and I may still have her divinity recipe tucked away somewhere.
Until I find it, this traditional version captures the light, fluffy, melt-in-your-mouth candy I associate with her Christmas sweets.
5. Nana’s Christmas Chocolate Pizza
Nana shaped her chocolate pizza into Christmas wreaths or trees and decorated them with red and green cherries. It was one of those special homemade candies that always stood out among the Christmas treats.
This chocolate pizza recipe from Plowing Through Life reminds me much more of the kind Nana made. It’s a rich chocolate candy filled with marshmallows, crispy rice cereal, and peanuts, with colorful toppings that make it perfect for Christmas.
While I can’t say it’s Nana’s exact recipe, it’s a wonderful way to bring back that old-fashioned Christmas candy tradition.
6. Mexican Wedding Cookies
These little powdered-sugar-covered cookies were always among my favorites. They’re also called snowball cookies or Russian tea cakes, depending on the recipe and family tradition.
They’re tender, buttery, and wonderfully crumbly, with that familiar snowy coating that makes them look right at home on a Christmas cookie plate.
7. Stained Glass Christmas Cookies
I loved the stained glass cookies with colorful candy windows. They’re made by cutting openings in the cookie dough and filling them with crushed hard candy, which melts into translucent little panes as the cookies bake.
They’re almost too pretty to eat, especially when the light shines through the candy.
8. Southern Pecan Pralines
One of my favorite candies to make was pecan pralines, using a recipe from The Cotton Country Collection, published by the Junior League of Monroe, Louisiana.
That cookbook has a special place in my kitchen history. I made my first spaghetti from a children’s cookbook, but after that, The Cotton Country Collection was the book I reached for before any other when I wanted a recipe. It’s where I learned most of what I knew about cooking.
Everybody seemed to have a copy. I could spend hours poring over its pages, discovering things I wanted to try.
My cookbook’s recipe is credited to Mrs. Charles Wilkins and uses sugar, water, vinegar, pecans, and butter. The recipe below is a different Southern version.
9. Old-Fashioned Peanut Brittle
Peanut brittle is one of those classic candies that immediately looks at home in a tin of homemade Christmas treats.
With its crisp, caramelized sugar and roasted peanuts, it’s a lovely contrast to the softer fudge, pralines, and divinity elsewhere in this collection.
10. Butter Almond English Toffee
Buttery toffee topped with chocolate and almonds makes a wonderful addition to a homemade Christmas candy assortment.
It has that satisfying snap when you break it into pieces, and it keeps the old-fashioned candy-making theme going alongside the fudge and pralines.
11. Classic Spritz Cookies
Spritz cookies are one of those instantly recognizable Christmas cookies, pressed into little trees, wreaths, stars, and other festive shapes.
They’re buttery, delicate, and especially pretty with a few colored sprinkles. They’re also a good choice when you want a whole tray of cookies without rolling and cutting individual shapes.
12. Raspberry Thumbprint Cookies
Thumbprint cookies bring a little color to a Christmas cookie plate, with their buttery dough and bright centers of fruit preserves.
These raspberry almond thumbprints have a lovely balance of sweet and tart flavors, and they’re just the sort of cookie that looks like someone spent an afternoon baking for the holidays.
13. Classic Gingerbread Cookies
No collection of traditional Christmas cookies feels quite complete without gingerbread.
The warm spices, familiar shapes, and possibility of decorating them together make gingerbread cookies a holiday tradition all their own.
14. Homemade Cream Caramels
Soft homemade caramels are another old-fashioned candy that makes a lovely Christmas gift.
Wrapped individually in waxed paper, they have the look of something made with care in a family kitchen and tucked into a tin to share.
15. Classic Buttery Shortbread Cookies
Of all the Christmas cookies I’ve enjoyed over the years, simple shortbread is still my favorite.
No elaborate frosting, no fancy fillings, and no need to dress it up. Just that rich buttery flavor and tender, crumbly texture.
Sometimes the simplest recipes are the ones that stay with us the longest.
A Homemade Gift to Go With the Treats
If you’re packing up a batch to give away, my cozy kitchen gift basket ideas have a few ways to tuck homemade treats into a gift. A tin of cookies would pair nicely with a trivet from my Christmas crochet kitchen set. I’ve also rounded up easy crochet Christmas gifts you can actually finish if you’re making gifts for several people.
A Little Christmas Tradition Worth Keeping
Looking back, I don’t remember every dish that was served at every Christmas gathering. But I remember the sweets.
I remember who made the fudge, who brought the cookies, and the candies that appeared year after year.
Some of these recipes are close to the ones I grew up with, while others simply remind me of those Christmas gatherings. Either way, I hope you find something here that brings back a memory of your own—or becomes a new tradition for someone in your family.






















